Notre Dame Fire Sparks Both Controversy and Unity

  • Home
  • News
  • Notre Dame Fire Sparks Both Controversy and Unity

//PICTURED ABOVE: Firefighters desperately try to extinguish the fire to save the rest of the building from further damage. On April 15, Notre Dame de Paris burned and lost a significant part of the structure that brought worldwide attention.

On April 15, 2019, Catherine Berryman, a French teacher at Hockaday, was coming back to her room after lunch when she noticed she had masses of messages from friends, some of whom she had not spoken with in a long time.

The first message she read began with “Oh, so sorry, Notre Dame.”

The Notre Dame cathedral burned for nine hours from unknown causes. The start of the fire is currently under investigation and it is suspected to be an accident relating to renovations on the church’s spire ongoing at the time.

About one-third of the roof remains, with most of the roof and the spire of the cathedral destroyed, and remnants of the roof fell onto the stone vault and causing sections of the said vault to collapse. Most stone vault sections remained intact. All the cathedral’s relics survived, as most were kept in the adjoining sacristy, while some artwork and most sculptures were previously removed for renovations. Furthermore, most other articles in the cathedral were either undamaged or are able to be restored.

Thanks to the renovations ongoing to the cathedral’s spire, most articles were not damaged, with copper statues on the roof and other decorations moved temporarily mere days before the fire. France has been trying to raise funding for renovations through government funds and private donations for a renovation program proposed in the late 2010s. The renovation was, as a whole, estimated to cost around 100 million euros.

While funding was difficult to raise, the fire at Notre Dame inspired a heavy flow of donations to its reconstruction and renovation, around one billion US dollars as of this article’s publication raised by April 17, 2019, or in two days time since the fire. Companies and families alike donated, though the amount raised in such a short time has drawn controversy. Hockaday Junior Claire Trochu noticed how donations may have stemmed from a sense of competition between donators.

“The Pinot family pledged 100 million euros that night and, because of this, one of their competitors, another rich family, also donated 200 million euros,” said Trochu. “It sort of fueled this fire of big companies and philanthropists to donate.”

The controversy across social media, like Twitter and Tumblr, sparked over how quickly the money was raised for the cathedral sparks from how other causes, like reducing plastic use and funding social change, receive far less attention and supports.

“While this is an important cause, there is something to be said about how fast this happened,” Trochu said, “as opposed to the social problems we have, not only in France and around the world, and how much trouble those causes have fundraising. That doesn’t mean the money shouldn’t go to Notre Dame, it’s just a little concerning.”

Furthermore, controversy arose over how news outlets focused on the Notre Dame versus other tragic events happening around the same time, such as the Sri Lanka bombings and burning of churches in Louisiana. Maddy Charest, a sophomore at Hockaday, believes that the Notre Dame was reported so heavily upon due to its cultural significance.

“I think that the Notre Dame is a worldwide, universal landmark everyone knows,” said Charest. “Other things going on are equally as tragic and important in the world, but they didn’t touch as many lives as the Notre Dame did.”

In addition, the fire was emotionally touching for many worldwide, like Berryman.

“I understand that the media was trying to cover it because people wanted it,” Berryman said. “I think there was a need for people to see and understand.”

With global attention and a worldwide response, a sense of unity rose from the tragedy, as people in France and out mourn the burning of the Notre Dame. In France, people gathered near the Notre Dame and sang hymns while firemen worked to control the blaze. People all over the world, from average people to high-profile politicians, have shown an outpouring of support for France and grief for the burning of Notre Dame across social media.

“France has had a lot of terrorist attacks recently, between the one in Paris and the one in Nice,” Trochu said. “The French people have been dealing with a lot of tragedy recently, but this feels different because everyone can relate to the Notre Dame. There’s less hate and anger, and instead, it’s grief and love that I feel are happening.”

Story by Catherine Sigurdsson

Photo provided by Flickr user manhhai


Catherine Sigurdsson

Affectionately nicknamed Salt by her friends, Catherine is a senior who loves tearing through books, eating sushi, and attending jiu-jitsu classes. She loves anything matcha and will happily show you pictures of her cat.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

cbd oil: cbd oil and crohns in full effect definition isolate cbd oil best cbd for pain relief green mountain cbd capsules funny cbd oil cartoon memes palmetto harmony medterra promo code cbd wholesale private label therapeutic medical definition charlotte web cbd stock cbd oil 58501 does cbd show on drug tests cbd oil legal idaho cbd american shaman water soluble cbd in georgia phyto cbd review cbd oil in texas tbc benefits cbd oil to treat alcoholism healing through movement review plus cbd oil total plant complex human doctor and rose cbd for sleep dosage hold my juice box can cbd oil help somebody that is having nightmares legal skin cbd sperm marijuana helps allergies cw cbd capsules revision skin care reviews shops that sell cbd near me cannabis oil products promotion code for cbd where to purchase cbd cbd oil cross lanes wv cb1 weight gainer cbd with thc snoops obama ablis cbd cbd oil made anxiety worse costco cbd oil cbd oil smells like weed cba number cbd oil 700 mg fountain of youth cbd does cbd oil show up on drug tezt because of you traduccion paradigm wholesale cbd oil how much cbd oil to take

male enhancement: nitrates medication raise male libido blue headache pill penis enlargement breakthroughs diabetes and ed low libido hormone when to take cialis before intercourse men who have unrelented sex drive permanent penis enlargment thyroid medication increase sex drive how you make your dick big male enhancement in richmond virginia does stretching your penis really work extends male enhancement reviews increase naturally penis size how many vitmain e can i take at once to help with sex drive best testosterone booster reviews viagra foods to avoid guy takes male enhancement pill how much does a penis weight doctor you do fat transfer for male enhancement sex vitamin for male maxocum male enhancement viagra bottle new male enhancement pill 007 danger of the traction method of penis enlargement thunder and lightning male enhancement pills virectin vs extagen vs vasoplexx vs vigrx plus best male enhancement pills sold on amazon why do guys lose interest jo male enhancement cream viagra directions for taking male enhancement food supplement why did dead steal the viagra nitroproxen pills male enlarge penis penile girth increase surgery how does high testosterone lower sex drive how to make your penis healthy what can i take to temporarily kill my sex drive male rhino blue pill what does viagra do to a girl which of the choices below is not a function of testosterone viagra 3 free coupon cream for penis enlargement viagra max dosage viagra phone prescription same day viagra were your gains skow and steady or in rapidly in brief periods penis enlargement negative side effect of long term viagra use penis enlargement new technology

vape: best vape to quit smoking reddit mod and tank kit what is a vape pod what are the negative effects of vaping washington vape company has anyone died from vaping ebay vape products buy thc vape oil vape juice tsa nicotine vape oil varavo vape how to fill crown uwell vape battery box uwell crown coils titanium what is a box mod vape mhow to smoke voopoo panda finder 250 pod drop stego wrap vapor barrier how to make o with vape vicks vapor rub coupon uwell rafale sub ohm tank reddit jungle juice vape liquid online e cig shop 50mg vape juice compared to cigarettes voopoo drag voltage settings i cant taste my vape juice buy vape smoke juice marlboro 60ml bottle vape juice gold vaporizer pen harmful e cigarette e cigarette starter kits best prices does e juice go bad the council of vapor mini volt priv smok smok pistol grip topbox mini coils atlanta vape showcase ofrf gear smok rebuildable atomizer best batteries for mechanical mods island vape smok majesty 225w tc box mod honey vape uwell nunchaku manual pdf does vaping kill you no atomizer uwell how to fill voopoo pod what tanks will work with the voopoo drag mini vaporesso polar 220w

exam: Pass4sure 9A0-158 Book Pdf With Accurate Answers, Reliable and Professional 9L0-207 Ebook Pdf with PDF and VCE Engine, Helpful APP-DSK-100 Certification With Low Price, Test-inside IC3-3 Practice Test Pdf Is Updated Daily, Reliable and Professional 350-029 Online Exam Guaranteed Success, Most Accurate 650-157 Exam Test Is The Best Material, First-hand 642-681 Practice Exam Pdf With Accurate Answers, Latest SK0-002 Practice Exam Pdf For All Candidates From All Over The World, Sale Latest DC0-100 Labs For Sale, Free M9520-233 Cert Exam Sale, Offer HP2-Z17 Online Exam For Each Candidate, Download Latest HP0-136 Test Prep Is Your Best Choice, Provides PHR Exam Demo For Each Candidate, High Pass Rate 000-711 Training Guide With 100% Pass Rate, Real P2040-060 Certification Exam For All Candidates From All Over The World, Most Hottest 000-M68 Practice Test Pdf On Sale, Pass the 000-M249 Dump , Prepare for the PART2 Dump Test Online Sale, Free CSDA Material Pdf Is What You Need To Take, Most Important BH0-009 Exam Engines Is The Best Material, Prepare for the 70-346 Training Online, Money Back Guarantee 1Z0-418 Vce Download Is Updated Daily, SelfTestEngine S90-01A Vce with PDF and VCE Engine, Most Hottest ST0-202 Exam Topics Is Your Best Choice, Provides VCP-410 New Questions Latest Version PDF&VCE,

weight loss: dr wasim deeb jacksonville fl diet recipes to lose weight fariborz davoodi keto hamburger bake recipes women fat burner how can i lose weight by doing nothing shred one supplement carbohydrates per day to lose weight diet pills used by tim mcgraw keto recipes sesame chicken diet pills from the 1980s walmart protein powder to lose weight recipes with egg whites keto what is healthy weight keto recipes for a slow cooker what can we drink to lose weight best unhealthy ways to lose weight fast slimming supplements do you lose weight after coolsculpting portion sizes for adults to lose weight eat food to lose weight appetite suppressant tea coffee juice diet plans to lose weight fast popular diet pills 2000s adzuki beans help lose weight weight gaining diet plans what is the most weight i can lose in 2 months do weight loss pills work with diet and exercise how to lose weight fast for woman over 40 how many calories does a 300 lb man needs to burn to lose weight how much carbs to cut to lose weight dates appetite suppressant can i lose weight with pancreatitis my body refuses to lose weight are there any prescription medications that help lose weight fast how to lose water weight pills do treadmills make you lose weight diet pills for diabetics type 2 how to give the best head step by step feed dog fruits to lose weight gain weight before losing weight how many calories does a 145 lb active female need to lose weight 35 percent lose weight he is trying cartoons diet 2 go keto mushrooms ground beef recipes rapid weight loss for woman best fda approved appetite suppressant quick way to lose 5 pounds in 3 days eat chips and lose weight

face mask: n95 mask what is that self rescuer respirator n100 face masks clay face mask walmart surgical masks vs dust mask when sick 3m 6000 series full face mask carrier korean surgical mask outfit what respirator mask to use cool japanese surgical mask moldex dust mask for woodworking chanyeol face mask what is better an n95 or n99 mask what does osha say about employee bringing in their own respirator to work masquerade masks full face luxuru what respirator for viruses different between 3m 8000 particle respirator vs 3m 8511 particulate n95 respirator north 7700 respirator parts jayjun anti dust mask review softseal silicon molded small niosh n95 pj masks face mask template n95 fasion respirator mask with iodine caster mascarilla descartable n95 3m 6300 half mask respirator manual what do the various yes to face masks do mers coronavirus 2017 how to make face masks without avocado 3m vflex n95 mask singapore how to wear a mask without your face getting wet osha how long wear respirator at a time dust mask and nanoparticles do you need a respirator for welding supreme mouth mask allied project partners dust mask what are medical disposables particulate mask 3m coronavirus teaching resources diy face mask for cystic acne 3m mask 6800 is the trader joes hydrating face mask burns 3m face mask sleep in what to do if your face is red from a face mask nexcare 3m anti pollution dust mask coronavirus in fiv cats shower shield face pool paint lowes golden statewarrriors irving face shield 3m n95 respirator flu mask agents of shield green tentacle face alpha defense fleece face shield